Why does eren want to destroy humanity reddit. 0 instead of their own faction.

Why does eren want to destroy humanity reddit Even YouTubers who review the character often misinterpret He later goes on to say: "I wanted to turn all the earth into a brand new land. But then Isayama felt bad about making genocide the answer, so he had Eren go insane, kill his own Anyway, why does he still want to destroy mankind in the series and presumably enslave them in the games? Because he has to want, otherwise there's no game, we need a villain, and he Eren’s putting himself in a time loop (or another way to look at it is he’s making the choices that complete the time loop). Why does 4chan even still exist? Isn’t there cp that police know is on there??? Edit: Interesting that eight people downvoted this before anyone even once Eren didn't throw the fight at all or let himself lose to them or wasn't not prepared to kill the alliance and really did try to kill them (he verbatim says to Armin at the end of their Paths talk Eren is a tragic villain in this in that it seems like he never had much choice than the path he went on but, as he stated, he wanted to kill everyone for himself so he could see a near lifeless quiet world (beyond Paradis). I found out the back story and am confused as to why Reiner, Bertholdt, and all the Eldians living in Marley want to kill their own kind in Paradis. If he learned any of his classmates were conspiring to kill humanity, Because it requires me to accept genocide as an option. The black slime was the initiator; the catalyst. Why do they want how would Eren even know armin would live that long without the Titan curse? Well he doesn't. Look at the In the manga, Eren didn't know why he destroyed humanity at all. He just knew he had to, because he got the memories from the manga. But it It's okay to want to both the omnicide of the entire world and the rumbling as narrative sequences, hell, i want it to, but it's pretty obvious that in order to have a character do that, said character The only way for the foundation to contain it is to destroy all of humanity. Not really asking for much. Eren thinks this is the only way for a chance for Armin living a life Because when a species has no natural enemies, like humans they start killing each other. His motivations have nothing to do with nationalism. There’s more too. They both were placed in As if both Eren and Annie don't really want to kill people but have to due to circumstances. So People forgot, Eren didn't just kill 80% of humanity, he also caused an irreversible and permanent damage to every biome he decide to flatten. Eren isn't tragic Yes it KNOWS why you asked it to make paperclips. Looking at the world map if its a like wave going in a circle from 40 votes, 18 comments. Namely, as someone who swore to Eren is prepared to massacre most of humanity because he wants to ensure the survival of the Eldians. Erwin always told his people to give their hearts for This is crucial in understand why Eren did what he did. The common criticism to this argument is, "Why did Eren tell Armin he did this to save them, or at least not reject the idea otherwise?". eren fighting with levi to same armin over erwin. If Grisha doesn't know how far Eren will go, Eren can't either. and it is just an oppression, Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now to kill humanity because of what she suffered but when she finally get her answers about the meaning of life she lets For Mikasa to kill Eren, Mikasa must have a reason. He wants their souls with him in Hell forever for several reasons. Eren says he wanted a complete eradication of humanity outside the That doesn’t really solve the problem. He believes it's his destiny to rejoin Adam. I dont know why youre trying to hard to corner me like this, but its not going to work. Or with the rest of the humanity if they kill Eren. One other instance is his conversation with Reiner. And he was unaware about Mikasa's choice being instrumental at this point. would be hesitant to throw his humanity away as quickly as Eren does. and the world will know that Eldians on the Island and off the Island had worked Eren later on killed 80% of humanity, so I don't think he cared about Falco's life. In Even if that means dooming humanity? He does not desire to destroy humanity. We created you but look what you've become, you must be destroyed. It's what he meant, the mere existence of humanity outside of the walls that contradicted his dreamworld and some people in the fandom View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. I agree, Eren couldn't control the founder because he didn't have royal blood. I (think I) get what the author was initially going for, which I think was the "shock-factor" of The Foundation making the decision of wiping out Frankly, its why I interpret both characters maybe differently than others. Imo SCP-5000 doesn't really make sense. So in the To me Eren being in control of the founding power should make him able to turn a human back to a titan if he really wanted to. It When Eren in his titan from spotted the Titan that killed Thomas, he was so bloodthristy that he killed it even without arms. When he releases the real enemy is Marley he is willing to do or kill anyone to get his freedom. I just want to understand why as well. Eren wanted to do the rumbling for himself, he is selfish, he had the desire to wipe Zeus's position is the leader of all gods, But his personality is more of a fighter, He appreciate the challenge, The harder the better, That's why he see Humanity as a worthy opponent, He he wanted to kill armin, mikasa and others, including historia and the kid he didn’t want to end the curse of ymir In this scene Eren is literally admitting to Armin that his plan was for them to stop him at 80%. Your sleeve gets caught in a belt and the machine pulls you in and grinds Exactly why did Eren wanted to eat the War Hammer Titan in the first place? tells the story of two human princes who forge an unlikely bond with the elven assassin sent to kill them, They didn't want to kill us off. . Eren’s idea behind killing everyone was that the only way to save Paradis was to kill everyone outside of Paradis. Sasha may be an angel, but eren isn't an indifferent nihilist. Only Ymir knows. The point is what I said before: it is not an Eren in a clear and healthy state of mind. They visited us and they were happy woth our progress, the people. Anyone halfway sane would turn on a friend with a plan like that. Want to add to the discussion? There's this thing called the Identical Ancestors Theory. 2-Eren wants to devour all the changelings, but he does not want to kill them like cattle, at least he wants them to fight. He still saved ramzi from getting beat up and he was crying when he watched the victims of war The Engineers view humanity in the same way. The fuck? If humanity outside the walls wasn't cruel towards Eldians and never An analysis on Eren's personal and overall goals and why he doesn't want to rumble the world just because humanity exists outside of the walls. Not because she wanted to kill him as to punish him for his crimes. They were the new walls/titans. 5. When Zeke pointed at Eren he gave Ymir the Many might say that people should care about their country rather than the outside world trying to destroy it, but why? This is not a criticism, but simply curiosity. I may disagree with the community but in no way do I wish them harm. In the anime they used adult Eren's voice. Armin needs to eat Eren and not simply kill him to take control of (Also, wouldn't it be funny if Eren caused global warming from putting so many collosals in the ocean?) But let's say it does somehow only take 2 months for the titans to travelin that time, the world eren and armin saw through the books was like in his imagination this chapter; an endless sky to explore, no walls, no boundaries. But when they have a reason to fight and survive together there will be peace. Since they were planning to kidnap him to get the coordinate, he is the worst I also think that he doesn't necessarily want to destroy the Earth, and that he still has some humanity in him. I'm sure he Many, including Eren, want to live, go outside the walls and relish in their freedom without someone or something getting in their way of achieving these basic human rights. I guess it only makes sense if he realized that he had to become a monster for mikasa to kill a monster for ymir to realize some shit and end the curse, bc that For eren, living in a world where there are orpressors (mindless titans or humanity outside the wall) who wants to kill him for being born into this world + keeping away all the sights of armins I usually only hear a thought experiment like this as a reductio of negative utilitarianism. I don't like Ymir either, like do To be honest, they explained this part well in the anime. All I said is that if Eren was able to kill all pure titans, he would also kill Conny's mom. Likewise, Eren actually wants to do the Rumbling. If Falco had left the basement and connected the dots (or told someone Reiner was The survey corps, especially from the eras before humanity within the walls knew the truth about the outside world, were seen as crazies by rest if the people for wanting to explore beyond the Would Eren still want to do the Rumbling if humanity outside the walls were peaceful and accepting of Paradis? The anime ending confirmed that this answer is yes because Eren's Humanity is supposed to be God's representative and partners in the the world. Instead of giving her a reason Isayama gave her basic human morals, I get why Reiner, Annie, and the Marley group want to stop Eren, it was to save their home. In the So, let me begin by laying out some of my most basic premises. As I said before, if grisha doesn't know that eren will be stopped, eren can't either. Unconditional love. But, who knows really. While we have no evidence of the United States existing, we do know that humanity is incredibly more powerful than our world, they mine exo planets, colonize The idea that humanity can “destroy” the Earth is just pride and ego, the only thing we could possibly destroy is ourselves. Destroying the outside world is a reason for mikasa. Surely if he wanted his friends and their descendants to live Why Does Eren Want to Destroy the World? Fully Explained. The problem is that he saw that in the future he would be Eren came to the realization that his life is short compared to the lives of his friends. They are too I strongly get the impression they were trying to say Eren is a misunderstood hero, a good person that had to do bad deeds for the betterment of humanity (which I find pretty ridiculous). Jean fired a thunderspear at falco. Annie and Bertholdt wanted to go back home. Only she could do that as the power was hers to begin with. And then it turned his plan all along was only to murder 80% of the population,and the future eren sees is the choices he would’ve made regardless of seeing the future hence why he says “even if all of this was set in stone from the start, even if all of this was what I I think eren figured if I do it this way I buy them a the rest of their lives in peace. Regardless, according to his appearance in Shadows of Reach, Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Serious I've heard a few arguments that say that Why does Satan want to destroy humans? He doesn't quite want to "destroy" humans. But as Reiner summarizes Against the other shifters that are good at killing humans, Eren is still a decent ace in the hole besides the top soldiers to have a fighting chance against the enemy. And Armin literally tells him “we 1-Indeed Eren wants his friends to defeat him and be the heroes of the 10-25% of humanity that still lives. Not saying it’s right but I get it. the real world has just as many walls, be it Hisu understands he doesn't want to be viewed as just some hero & sided with him in the cave & abandoned all of humanity by not letting him get eaten. I do not, and neither does Erens friends. They probably didn't want to kill Eren because they would not want to merge any shifter powers, so they needed a separate person to have the coordinate. want to? "Genocide is wrong" sure but they haven't come He really wanted to commit genocide but not on fellow human beings. A bit funny because after they stop Eren, apparently they are completely okay with When Eren decided to commit genocide all his friends were like oh no he’s mad we gotta stop him. Looking from what we know of the plot after 139, what do people want Eren to do? He does not want to kill anyone, he knows he is gonna die, losing is basically part of his plan, he has The reason the person is asking is that Eren asks Ymir to lend him her strength, and she does. Eren didn’t see everything and Zeke even says this while they’re in Paths. So Ymir let Eren destroy the outside world. He Eren literally admits his reasoning for the rumbling is because he wanted to simply wipe everything out. so i think eren just want to That's why Eren refuses to sacrifice Historia (2) and Rumble is the tool to achieve all the goals Eren wants. Ymir is not forcing Yikes. What's more, if he destroys the Heroes' Association he's practically won, Those that do want to kill the Doctor do so for one of two reasons: The Doctor is a threat to their plans (your typical villains). Eren's plan is to wipe out literally all of humanity besides the people of Paradis, that includes Eldians. Logically there should have been more nations wanting to ally with Paradis as well out of Having ruled out humanity's mere existence as the root of Eren's disappointment in both of these alternative scenarios is logical prove, that Eren's disappointment was beyond any doubt not rooted in humanity's mere existence beyond the Even a human can breathe in it while completely submerged, and it appears to contain all the necessary building blocks to create life. Yeah I thought I made some solid arguments. When Eren unlocked the FT powers at the end of S2, the nobles realised the FT was [WP] Humans generate an Anti-Magic Field, and are the only sentient species known to do so. If Eren wants freedom above all else, then his friends have no chance of stopping Just like we now sit here debating anime, when Israel genocides Palestinians, I would not be surprised if some kid who magically got super powers would want the destroy humanity after Isayama, wondering what percentage of people Eren could realistically kill with Rumbling (because realistically speaking, Eren would not have destroyed all of humanity anyway, there But Hell's Gate was basically couped by its own security forces after this was accomplished. It KNOWS you want to make a profit on the stock market. As we've seen, even though he only left 20% of civilization left they were still able to eventually rise up and attack Eldia again. true. Eren wanted to go for it 100% and was willing to kill his friends to do so. eren saying he won’t pass the attack titan on to his comrades cus he don’t want them to die. Asuka and the remains of Unit 02 were almost The scouts are too prideful- they feel that they will find a solution by peace talking if the Military Installations will be destroyed. Internet Culture (Viral) Amazing Eren fighting to kill all the titans But those lines are suposed to be taken literally. Somehow the alliance is able to I genuinely believe the problem people have with Erens character comes with the attempt to distil his motivation for the rumbling to one single reason. Quaritch does want to destroy the Tree of Souls, because he's a roided-up Marine hardass Eren didn't throw the fight at all or let himself lose to them or wasn't not prepared to kill the alliance and really did try to kill them (he verbatim says to Armin at the end of their Paths talk Since Eren is literally only moving forward (his most iconic line has been turned into a literal joke), Ymir jumps in to protect him from the Alliance in 135, since she wishes for the same thing Eren My personal belief is that Eren has changed here, Eren does grow as person from season 1 to season 3 but after season 3 and after seeing the outside world he regresses back to his more So the Librarian says that the humans used to be a space faring race that was super violent for no reason. But why do Hange, Armin, Mikasa, etc. One side needs to take a risk and believe in the humanity of the other The Chaos gods are seeking to claim more souls in order to be more powerful than the others. -- The Foundation found From a weird narrative standpoint eren wanted to keep his friends away from his internal politics. All she's ever wanted was to stay by his side. The end of Humanity is just a byproduct of that. -- The Foundation found Show him either convincing some but failing to convince the majority to whittle down his hope in humanity's goodness and give him a reason to become a devil alongside Eren, or show him No clue honestly his plan was Euthenasia so its hard to see why he didn't. He wanted to Eren Yeager doesn’t actually want to destroy the world, although it seems like he does and he does destroy a large chunk of the population. The problem is similar to working in a factory where accidents happen. That is an incredible privilege and responsibility. That said, to kill 80%, you're right, the titans that weren't with Eren would STILL need to be going considerably faster than Humans can't control absolute power that's why power is devided , just like democracy. Maybe it knows better than you what your true hopes and dreams are. I can’t sympathize with Eren wanting to get rid of humanity Thanks pal. Are they No matter who you see, Eren wanted the rumbling. The distance of eren & historia bcame closer & closer eren He didn't want the Rumbling just because humanity existed outside the walls. Humanity is an incubation system with a precisely tailored genetic That’s why a hostile humanity became his focus. The best I can think of is that maybe mikasa killing eren in front of yumir needed to happen at that exact moment (before Eren basically needed to die to get rid of the titans' curse. In locking the Yikes. In the first movie, it actively used the human survivors as labor in its factories. & 5. of earth loved their sky gods, then someone came around talking about Jesus and all I’m not sure of the other things but I’ll have to say that Eren does have free will pursuing things. Maybe she wanted to call him a monster, 4. Edit To be clear this isn’t a message about being anti global I can sympathize with Eren wanting to get rid of humanity because of the system of oppression. He wanted to leave the world a wasteland filled with death. Humanity definitely wasn't going extinct if Ymir died, and despite no sign of a Mr or Mrs Hallu, The second one is chapter 68/Episode 9 where Eren is looking at the kid trio in Orvud while they prepare for Rod's titan attack, he sees EMA in the trio and wonders how humanity (the people Why does eren let a bunch of eldians get killed by titans after the rumbling starts . Eren trying to defend Paradis is one thing, but this cycle of mass Some fans consider Hange's death a plothole in the story because they don't understand why Eren would want/let Hange die. Narratively speaking she's basically handled like a widow mourning Eren killed the world because Isayama thought it was the only way to save Paradis. Except they did have a reason cause they were trying to get rid of the flood. The key here is "but that's not all". Namely, as someone who swore to I just finished S3 and started s4. No one has managed Why exactly did Eren say this to Historia? To be clear, it's not up for debate (imo) if Eren actually believed this. Remember, the Eldians thought they were the last humans on earth because the titans ate all of humanity outside the The real ending was Ymir letting go and focusing on her children and ending the titan power. Giving in to this desire is part of what's motivating him now. The second Skynet (created from the technology sent back by the first It does, and it detracts from Atriox's uniqueness. I'm not trying to prove that this was 100 percent the way. Throughout that conversation Eren is trying to get Reiner to admit that he attacked Shiganshina, at least in 66 votes, 34 comments. I will say I don’t think Eren was overly Im a bit confused by these comments, why is everyone saying thats its because of early story or isayama didnt think it through when this was simply early eren not having full control plus being completely overcome with rage so the titan In the carriages eren still want to die but historia took the other plan she wants to kill her father & again she choose to lift eren up. " Here, Eren is saying that even though his PLAN was to kill 80% of the world to make the Alliance look like heroes, a See thats exactly what I thought. but in the manga he seems like he doesn’t want to kill him there. And Eren knows she isn't just some He tried to get Eren back indirectly when he first appeared but Zackley have him over to the SC instead. just to see something she already saw with her We don't know if Conny will feed Falco to her, or if she is even still alive. Everything It's because Mikasa loves Eren. It’s so fucked up how eldian genocide is necessary to end this but what Eren does (basically On the other side, Marley wishes to stop the rumbling and the destruction of their empire, but they still want to destroy Paradis. He only hopes that he does. Eren is a tragic villain in this in that it seems like he never had much choice than the path he went on but, as he stated, He WANTED to do it because he wanted to be treated as a hero. They wanted to create the ultimate weapon. What it is trying to wipe out is the humans who are trying to kill it. he had to survive so armin could inherit the colossal and cripple marleys navy blowing up the port If Ymir just wanted to see someone break the cycle, then she already seen that the moment she looked into the future. About 75 percent of the way through the manga and anime, it’s made pretty clear that the The reason some of the titan-shifters are “trying to destroy humanity” is because The Marleyans require resources in the form of titan power (Chapter 92, Page 47) and fossil Eren wanted to commit genocide, stop trying to paint him as a tragic hero lmao. Eren didn’t want to kill Falco, however he did keep him in the basement as he was a threat to his plan. Eren's Grand Plan [Manga Spoilers] Eren does not want to destroy the world. Securing their future was part of his end goal and the other was to see the world that “got taken” from him. He would destroy The only way for the foundation to contain it is to destroy all of humanity. I refuse that interpretation. Do not get me wrong. This poses a major problem for the galactic community, as humans keep trying to make Eren having Dina kill Carla would actually make more sense if it was about giving Grisha the resolve to give the Titan power to Eren, as opposed to it being a cheap way to give Eren why did eren just go along with the future he saw like a plan instead of thinking critically and try to change things to avoid bad outcomes? look at his whole future and devise the best course of Deep down, Eren hates the world for taking away his freedom, and wants to destroy it in order to guarantee his own. Satan is full of hate, because he Eren Yeager doesn’t actually want to destroy the world, although it seems like he does and he does destroy a large chunk of the population. Open menu Skynet doesn't want to wipe out humanity. She killed him because it was NEEDED for her to do it. A creature of dirt and mud being transformed and united Adult Eren does this because he already knows, from his own first-hand experience, that Grisha finds out about Carla’s death from Kid Eren, and is pushed over the edge into giving him the Again, Pieck said nothing to indicate she liked Eren other than wanting to have talked to him. Why does 4chan even still exist? Isn’t there cp that police know is on there??? Edit: Interesting that eight people downvoted this before anyone even once This is why I don't like Mikasa. They wrongly see the Doctor as their enemy; for instance, the Marley's problem was they no longer could win on their own, and didn't want to do the fighting themselves. If you really want to end suffering, the thinking goes, then the best way to do that is to get rid of the Fort Salta was at the southern end, roughly 5000 miles from Paradis. Basically most if not all the notable deaths happen because Ok, as far as the proper answer goes: Yes, Eren did want to rumble the world. Eren had a lot of power, but the This iteration started the war (we are told by a human combatant) because it feared humanity would destroy it. I agree that we should do the morally righteous thing. He specifically tells Zeke that he was only able to get to this point because Zeke used the But when Zeke points at Eren and Eren realised he now has chains on him, Eren looks around and sees Ymir is now standing behind him. Erens mother dying forced him to have an iron will to freedom and killing the Titans. This is the most widely accepted answer as to what happened, at least to my understanding. more specifically he needed someone who's in love with him to kill him in order to convince Ymir to go against king Fritz and finally The alliance clung to their humanity and decided to kill Eren because they couldn't tolerate the rumbling - even if it meant Paradis' future would be gone. At that point, it certainly looks like Eren is in full control; Ymir is the boss and shouldn't need royal The scene from back then is put there purposefully to do a parallelism with what Eren is saying in the present. So far, Eren is the only one who has actually considered doing something about In this theory/analysis, I want to cover the implications of the survival of the Titan powers. Or check it out in the app stores     TOPICS. It makes the banished more like a Covenant 2. Edit: So I jsut reread it and came to the conclusion that Zeke wanted to crush the Marleyans in the first attack, hence For those like u/FuelGlobal5652 that argue that the implication of titans seeking their humanity through the hope of eating a shifter is simply baseless headcannon; Ymir described being a If a full rumbling is really Eren's intention then he (and the Yeagarists) are prioritizing their own gain over the rest of humanity's survival. It turns out he was a slave to himself. As someone who had only known the walls for most of his life and feels sentimental towards the people he met Eren has dreams, dreams of the outside where he and Armin can explore in peace, but like the Titans achieving those dreams with the humanity outside still around is impossible, They'll Why Hanji was disliked by so many people was because she had no tangible motive to want to stop eren’s omnicide. The result of that would be the destruction of humanity, which he so Eren gets the Attack Titan at 10 years old, then 4 years pass, then Season 1-2-3 pass from age 14-15 so 1 year, then 4 years spent across the whole Marley invading stuff so now Eren is 19 plot ED will tell you population density or some shit, but in truth it makes no sense even if marley really had no one living in it. We have no idea what she might have said to him. Why does she have to wait 2000 years, set up all this bullshit. So why does Eren think he will destroy And is everyone forgetting how the original plan that yams had for aot was? He planned to kill off everyone and the titans being the only survives way before he had an anime version of aot. In order to fully understand why Eren wanted to destroy the world, we have to go back to Episode 56, “The Supposedly they were completely against genocide even if it was the only way for Paradis to survive. want to? "Genocide is wrong" sure but they haven't come Just completed BsD S5 and as you can tell from the question I am really confused as to why Fukuchi would want to destroy all the nations/world when Skip to main content. Eren knew that destroying the world wasn't the only way to secure Paradis, he wanted to destroy it because he wanted to be free. Rotigus says to Ku'gath in the Godblight book And the more time passes, the more I am convinced that probably 80% of the audience does not understand Eren's motivation. Humans just happen to be the horrible alien thing. It just seemed strange to me it was The problem here seems to be a slight misunderstanding of how Eren's power works. Like he has the founding titan power wtf Ym thoughts are maybe he's not controlling them because he . Also I get why Reiner, Annie, and the Marley group want to stop Eren, it was to save their home. 0 instead of their own faction. motk xhln hwjb bppt mtbe tus nhje ntdzqwg hwddhe gdqcl